Dunkaroos
Dunkaroos
So simple, yet so amazing, this sweet snack was a favorite of pretty much everyone. Although they did have a few flavors, the original vanilla cookie with vanilla funfetti icing was definitely the tastiest. It's so simple to make these at home, so you totally should. Homemade Dunkaroos
Hi-C's Ecto Cooler
Hi-C's Ecto Cooler
Hi-C was the sugary, sweet and delicious juice box we all loved in the '90s. In particular, the limited-edition Ecto Cooler was even better because it was neon green and featured Slimer on the box. Although it's no longer in stores, you can recreate this Ghostbuster-themed juice at home (and now that you're older add alcohol if you want)! Homemade Ecto Cooler
Butterfinger BB's
Butterfinger BB's
These bite-sized bits were a favorite of Bart Simpson (and his slingshot) and as fun to eat as they were delicious. Sure you can still get the full bar, but the BB's always tasted better. Relive the magic and make this tiny treats yourself. Homemade Butterfinger BB's
Keebler Magic Middles
Keebler Magic Middles
We're not sure why these went away. What's not to love about a soft, chewy shortbread cookie with a gooey, melt-in-your-mouth fudgy center? Nothing! Bring the magic back home by making these beauties yourself. Homemade Magic Middles
Zima
Zima
Oh Zima. How we miss thee. Only the coolest cats had a Zima in their hands. Yet despite reaching cult status, this malt beverage lost its edge and is no longer in production. Good news for you is that you can recreate this refreshing classic at home (and yes, you must drink it out of a mason jar). Homemade Zima
Jell-O Chocolate Pudding Pops
Jell-O Chocolate Pudding Pops
These creamy, chocolately frozen treats were way better than ordinary fudge pops. Homemade Jell-O Pudding Pops
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Pies
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Pies
Although there were a few TMNT themed foods (hello Ninja Turtles Cereal!), these vanilla pudding filled pies with the green icing glaze by Hostess was by far THE BEST. This homemade version will totally have you saying "cowabunga!" Homemade Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Pie
McDonald's Fried Apple Pies
McDonald's Fried Apple Pies
Yes you can still get the baked apple pies, but they don't hold a candle to the original fried version (go figure). Throw your diet to the wind and whip up this '90s favorite ASAP. Homemade Dee-Fried Apple Pies
Reese's Cookie Crunch
Reese's Cookie Crunch
It was genius: place a chocolate cookie INSIDE a Reese's peanut butter cup for a crunchy twist on the classic candy. Apparently most people are purist, but it is quite easy to recreate this at home. Use this base recipe and simply add a chocolate wafer cookie to it. Bam. Homemade Reese's
Surge
Surge
This citrusy soda that had us bouncing off the walls for hours is something we all miss. Recreate the hype (and get a bit hyper yourself) with this homemade version. Homemade Surge
The Flintstones Pebbles Push-Up
The Flintstones Pebbles Push-Up
The Pebbles variety of this creamy, fun treat was the best because those "pebbles" were actually rainbow Nerds. Push up the fun factor by making this homemade orange push-up treat and sprinkle Nerds on top. Homemade Orange Push-Ups
Viennetta Ice Cream
Viennetta Ice Cream
Introduced in the U.S. by Breyers, this luscious log-shaped treat consisting of ribbons of creamy ice cream and crunchy chocolate was the perfect summertime treat. Still a favorite in Europe, if your craving this dessert in The States you can easily make it yourself. Homemade Viennetta
P.B. Crisps
P.B. Crisps
A crispy cookie filled with a sweet peanut butter cream and shaped like a peanut: Planters at it's finest. This treat didn't stay around for long, but it definitely hasn't been forgotten. This homemade version may not have the classic shape, but you're in this for the flavor right? Homemade P.B. Crisps
PBMax
PBMax
These snack (aka: candy) bars where made with real peanut butter, a crunchy wholegrain cookie and were covered in milk chocolate. It didn't stay on shelves long (apparently the Mars family didn't care for peanut butter), but it isn't hard to make these to keep on your own shelf. Homemade PB Max
Sprinkled Chips Ahoy Cookies
Sprinkled Chips Ahoy Cookies
Sprinkles are for winners, so it's no wonder that they made an excellent addition to the already tasty Chips Ahoy. Be a winner yourself by adding sprinkles to this copycat recipe to relive the glory days all over again. Homemade Chips Ahoy
Carnation Breakfast Bars
Carnation Breakfast Bars
In an attempt to eat something healthier than our sugar-laden breakfast cereals, the go to was Carnation Instant Breakfast shakes or an easier (and tastier) alternative, the breakfast bars. With a healthy dose of chocolate, this homemade version is just as good as the original. Homemade Carnation Breakfast Bars

Subscribe to the Oola Newsletter

Galaxy Ice Cream dishes Alli Ladd Read More
We'll Have S'more Of These Fries, Please new Sophie Handler Read More
Stories Of When Mom's Cooking Went Horribly, Horribly Wrong dishes Brianna Morton Read More
Cookie Settings